WHAT IS ARSENIC
?
-
A metalloid
of Group V A of the Periodic Table.
-
Exists
in oxidation state in the natural environment including +5, +3, +1
and -3 valence and rarely occurring in elemental form In various
oxidation states, can form many inorganic and organic compounds.
-
The common
valences of arsenic in unpolluted ground water of geogenic origin
are +3 and +5.
-
In the
natural environment, arsenic occurs in soils at an average concentration
of about 5 to 6 mg/KG
-
Arsenite
[As(III)], the reduced state in inorganic arsenic, is a toxic pollutant
in natural environment and is more soluble and mobile than the oxidized
state of inorganic arsenic, arsenate [As(V)].
ARSENIC
IN GROUND WATER
-
Arsenic
in ground water is generally present as an oxy-anion i.e., as arsenite
(H3AsO3) or arsenate (H3AsO4) or both.
-
The dominant
aqueous species vary depending on pH and Eh (redox potential) condition.
-
Occurrence
of arsenic in ground water is mostly due to leaching of geological
material, mineral precipitation, dissolution of unstable arsenic minerals
adsorption - desorption, chemical transformation within the formation,
and input from geothermal sources. Factors such as pH, Eh, solution
composition, competing and complexing ions, aquifer mineralogy, reaction
kinetics and hydraulics of ground water system influence the arsenic
concentration in ground water.
-
Environmental
conditions of the sediments have a greater influence on arsenic speciation
and mobility than the total concentration of arsenic in sediments.
-
As per
WHO standards, permissible limit of arsenic in drinking water is 0.01
mg/litre and as per BIS, permissible limit is 0.05 mg/litre.
HEALTH HAZARDS
OF ARSENIC IN GROUND WATER
-
Arsenic
is poisonous in doses significantly larger than 65 mg/litre and a
single large dose or repeated small doses of arsenic can cause poisoning.
-
Very large
doses of arsenic can cause death.
-
Excess
intake of arseniccauses irritation of the digestive tract leading
to gastro-intestinal disorders like pain, nausea, vomiting and diarrhea.
-
It can
lead to cardio-vascular disorders - decreased production of red and
white blood cells, abnormal heart function and blood vessel damage.
-
Prolonged
ingestion of arsenic can cause liver and/or kidney injuries and can
lead to neurological disorder causing a "pins and needles"
feeling in feet and hands.
-
Inorganic
arsenic when inhaled increases risk of lung cancer.
- Ingestion
of inorganic arsenic may also cause skin disorders like hyper-pigmentation,
hyper-keratosis, warts or corns on the palms and soles. Sometimes
warts or corns may develop into skin cancer.
EXTENT OF ARSENIC PROBLEM IN WEST BENGAL, INDIA
Occurrence of arsenic in ground water has been reported from all over
the globe viz. USA, Mexico, Chile, China, Mongolia, Germany, Japan,
Bangladesh, etc. In India, arsenic contamination in ground water came
to light in early eighties when a few cases of arsenic dermatosis
were reported from parts of Nadia, 24 Parganas (North and South),
Murshidabad, Hugli , Haora and Bardhaman districts of West Bengal.
Subsequently it was established that prolonged use of arsenic contaminated
ground water was the cause of the disease.
POPULATION
AFFECTED
At present, arsenic contamination is limited to isolated patches spread
over 68 blocks of eight districts affecting about 4.4 million population.
|
District |
Total area |
Total Population |
Arsenic
(Risk zone) (Km²) |
Population at risk |
No. of blocks\
Municipality |
% of area
affected |
% of population
at risk |
|
1. Malda |
3553.40 |
2637000 |
1095.00 |
540000 |
5 |
30.48 |
20.48 |
|
2. Murshidabad |
5362.43 |
4740000 |
2856.00 |
1168000 |
15 |
53.20 |
24.64 |
|
3. Nadia |
3916.00 |
3852000 |
3066.00 |
835000 |
13\1 |
78.43 |
21.67 |
|
4. North 24 Pgn. |
4094.00 |
7282000 |
4094.00 |
887000 |
19\7 |
100.00 |
12.18 |
|
5. Bardhaman |
6663.71 |
6051000 |
344.50 |
14000 |
2 |
5.16 |
0.31 |
|
6. Howrah |
1426.00 |
3730000 |
376.00 |
191000 |
3\1 |
26.30 |
5.12 |
|
7. Hoogly |
3200.45 |
4355000 |
207.70 |
30000 |
1 |
6.40 |
0.68 |
|
8. South 24 Pgn. |
9226.00 |
5715000 |
3200.00 |
772000 |
10 |
34.68 |
13.51 |
|
Total |
37441.99 |
38362000 |
15239.2 |
4427000 |
68/9 |
40.7 |
11.56 |
PROBABLE
SOURCES AND CAUSES FOR ARSENIC MOBILIZATION
A number of organizations and academic institutions are involved in
the Research & Development studies in order to ascertain the source
of arsenic and cause for arsenic mobilization in ground water. The studies
conducted so far indicate that :
-
Ground
water occurring mainly within shallow zones (20-60 mbgl) are characterized
by high iron, arsenic (>0.5 to 1 mg/l or above), calcium, magnesium
and bicarbonate with low chloride, sulphate, pH being above 7.
-
Sand
grains in the aquifers in the composite meander belt of the upper
delta plain are coated with iron and arsenic rich material.
-
Clay,
silty clay partings between the aquifers contain relatively higher
arsenic compared to sand - gravel sequence of the aquifer.
-
Arsenic
rich pyrite detected from borehole samples of a few locations is
the major source of arsenic contamination, on the assumption that
large scale ground water withdrawal leads to changes in the geochemical
environment which in turn decomposes pyrite to ferrous sulphate,
ferric sulphate and sulphuric acid.
-
Presence
of clay, peat etc. in the sediments having iron and arsenic sulphides
deposited in reducing environment is the principal source of elevated
arsenic concentration in ground water.
-
Changes
of pH, oxidation - reduction potential and aqueous chemistry may
mobilize the contaminant arsenic species already present in the
mineral matrix.
-
Phosphate
and arsenic content in the vadose zones are negligible.
-
Upper
sandy clay being tapped by dug wells has arsenic below detection
limit.
-
Pond,
tank or river water in these areas have been found to contain arsenic
within detection limit.
-
Some
researchers believe that leaching of arsenic in ground water has
been influenced by a number of factors like ground water withdrawal
for irrigation, percolation of oxygenated water through soil, application
of fertilizers containing phosphate and microbial reactions within
the soil. Some, however, consider that as the sulphate content of
ground water is very low and as sulphides are present in more clayey
strata which may not be taking part in the water turn over, it seems
less likely that arsenic comes from oxidized pyrite and arsenopyrite
as aerated ground water is drawn into the aquifer. According to
them, the aquifers are in a reduced state allowing the reduction
of ferric iron from oxides - hydroxides and with the release of
ferrous iron, adsorbed arsenic on the secondary iron and aluminium
phases is simultaneously released. High arsenic concentration is
generally associated with high iron content in alkaline ground water.
-
A combination
of oxidation and reduction phenomena coupled with changes introduced
by organic matter present in the sediments might have been responsible
for such high mobilization of arsenic. Large scale ground water
withdrawal for irrigation during summer months causes lowering of
water table and enhances oxidized zone which results into oxidation
phenomena and As(III) is converted into As(V), which is mobile and
is transported along ground water. However, during monsoon months,
the sediments are subjected to anaerobic conditions and reduction
of As(V) to As(III) takes place. It has been observed that such
conditions prevail 4 - 6 months in a year. The release of arsenic
may be 10 - 13 times more in the reduction process as compared to
that under oxidation process.
STUDIES CONDUCTED BY CENTRAL GROUND WATER
BOARD
The main objective of the studies being conducted by the Central Ground
Water Board in the arsenic affected areas of West Bengal is two-fold
:
-
Understanding
the ground water regime condition and mechanism of arsenic mobilization
Finding remedial measures to combat arsenic menace.
The activities to fulfill the above objectives include :
-
Periodic
monitoring of water levels and arsenic concentration from selected
monitoring stations.
-
Determination
of arsenic content in lithological samples and vadose water.
-
X-ray
diffraction studies to ascertain mineral composition of borehole
samples.
-
Isotope
studies to ascertain source and age of ground water and different
aquifers and to study aquifer - aquifer and surface water - ground
water interaction.
-
Hydrological
tests on arseniferous aquifers.
-
Study
of ground water flow using mathematical modelling.
-
Deep
exploratory drilling to delineate arsenic free aquifers in the
affected areas.
-
Study
impact of artificial recharge on shallow arseniferous aquifer.
-
Study
efficacy of different arsenic removal plants and filters.
-
Study
of arsenic rich ground water in food chain.
PROGRESS OF VARIOUS ACTIVITIES
1. Periodic monitoring of ground water regime
Monthly
monitoring of water levels was carried out from 62 key observation
wells during the period 1996-98 in the Yamuna sub-basin covering parts
of North 24 Parganas and Nadia - The depth to water levels were 5-6
mbgl during pre-monsoon and 2-3 mbgl during post-monsoon. Arsenic
concentration is higher in pre-monsoon than in the post-monsoon period.
44 key observation wells are being monitored on monthly basis in Barasat
- I block - Water levels range from 5.4 to 10.86 mbgl during pre-monsoon
period and from 1.81 to 6.59 mbgl during post-monsoon period. Arsenic
in ground water is maximum (1.75 ppm) in pre-monsoon period.
2. On-site
and laboratory studies for arsenic determination in lithological sample
Water samples were analysed in the field for different chemical parameters
viz. pH, EC, DO, Eh, As and Ferrous iron followed by detailed analysis
in the chemical laboratory - Ground water is found to be characterized
with low DO, low Eh, near neutral pH, high carbondioxide, high bicarbonate
and high ferrous iron thereby signifying the reducing environment
in aquifers containing arsenic.
Samples of water and sediments were collected from vadose zone and
analysed - Arsenic concentration is below detection limit of 0.001
mg/l, iron concentration is low being of the order of 1 mg/l, phosphate
concentration ranges from 0.25 to 1.25 mg/l and sulphate is low. In
sediment samples from the vadose zone, concentration of iron ranges
between 8-112 mg/Kg and that of arsenic between 0.05-6.5 mg/Kg.
Litho-samples collected down to depth of 250 mbgl at Birohi, Nadia
district were chemically analysed - Arsenic concentration is limited
down to a depth of 120 mbgl . Maximum arsenic concentration of 1.75
mg/Kg has been noticed at depth of 9-12 and 90-100 mbgl.
In South
24 Parganas, deep ground water is old. Carbon - 14 age : 5000 to 13000
years. Interconnection between shallow and deep aquifers is remote.
In shallow
aquifers in North 24 Parganas, ground water flow velocity has been
computed to be 17 cm per day. In Nadia and North 24 Parganas districts
around Yamuna river, interconnection between shallow aquifer and river
water is possible. Isotope study in districts of Nadia, Bardhaman,
Hugli districts shall be taken up once the proposed piezometers are
constructed and are ready for use.
5. Hydrological
tests on arseniferous aquifers
Pumping
tests have been conducted at 22 sites to determine aquifer parameters
and to monitor impact of pumping on arsenic concentration - Arsenic
concentration has been found to reduce progressively consequent to
pumping in most of the cases. The wells tested yielded between 21-43
m3 /hr of ground water. Transmissivity of aquifer was found to vary
from 400 - 538 m2/day and storativity varies from 1.3 x 10-2 - 0.33
x 10-5.
To understand the mobilization of arsenic in ground water, compressed
air was injected into shallow aquifer (55m) at Birohi, Nadia district
- In a span of 75 minutes, arsenic concentration changed from 0.02 ppm to below detection limit of 0.001 ppm. Iron content reduced from
10.6 to 1.10 mg/litre. The pH increased from 6.1 to 6.9, EC increased
from 640 to 680 and dissolved oxygen from 1.9 to 7.0.
6. Mathematic
modelling
A three
dimensional finite difference ground water flow model has been developed
by NIH. The model was tested in CGWB and certain modifications have
been suggested in ground water draft component.
7. Ground
water exploration
Exploratory
drilling has been taken up in Murshidabad, Nadia, and North 24 Parganas
districts with suitable well design and proper technique to seal off
contaminated aquifer - Arsenic free deep aquifers have been delineated
and successfully tapped in the depth range of 77 and 270 mbgl at 16
sites. The work is still continuing.
8. Artificial
recharge study
Experimental
studies are being carried out in North 24 Parganas district to study
the impact of artificial recharge on arsenic concentration in ground
water. At Ashoknagar, the artificial recharge measures could help
in reducing concentration of arsenic from 0.128 mg/l to <0.001
mg/l in a span of 3 months during October to December. At Joypur village,
the work is in progress.
9. Evaluation
of arsenic removal plants and domestic filters
16 community
based arsenic removal plants and domestic filters using different
removal techniques have been tested three times in three different
periods - The efficacy of these equipment was found to be 75 % .
10. Study
of the effect of arsenic rich ground water on food chain
Studies
to assess the effect of arsenic rich ground water on food chain are
under progress.
FUTURE
WORK PROGRAMME
- Continuation
of the exploration to delineate deep arsenic free aquifer in arsenic
infested area and construction of suitably designed tubewell for providing
arsenic free water.
- Opening an
Arsenic Mitigation Cell within Central Ground Water Board to
expedite the Research & Development work on arsenic mitigation.
- Continuation
of isotope study to precisely differentiate shallow arseniferous aquifer
from the deep arsenic free aquifer.
- Experimental
study to ascertain the impact of artificial recharge of arsenic
contaminated shallow aquifer.
- X Ray
diffraction studies of the undisturbed core samples to identity
arsenic bearing minerals in depth & space.
- Chemical
analysis of the lithological samples to decipher the extension of
arsenic bearing zone in space and time.
- Study on food
chain in the arsenic infested area.
- Details study
on the efficacy of the arsenic removal filters/ plants introduced in
arsenic infested areas of West Bengal.
.
. |