Ground Water and Geophysics TOP
 
Geophysical surveys for Ground Water exploration in India started in 1930’s and Geological Survey of India initiated the systematic studies in 1945. National Geophysical Research Institute started the surveys in 1960’s and a phenomenal increase in its application was noticed in 1970’s. By that time the Central Ground Water Board (CGWB) as well as State Ground Water Departments also initiated the surveys. 

The main objective of geophysical investigations is acquisition of maximum sub-surface information through a systematic coverage of the entire area. In hard rocks, vertical electrical soundings (VES) got the maximum application. Other techniques like Self Potential (SP), Induced Polarization (IP), Mise-a-la-masse of electrical method, magnetic, seismic refraction , electromagnetic (the horizontal loop and very low frequency - VLF) methods have also been used as and when required.

Aeromagnetic, seismic and deep borehole data of other agencies were also analysed for their effective utilization in ground water exploration.  CGWB has so far carried out about 2,000 VES and electrically logged 560 bore holes apart from few VLF profiles. These surveys are being carried out using the time tested geophysical equipment. These enormous data have been used in getting the standardized resistivity values for various electrical layers in different hydrogeological environments vis-à-vis occurrence of ground water.

 
Geophysical Equipment TOP
 
 

The Central Region, Nagpur is equipped with the following instruments:

1)      Resistivity meter - ABEM Terra Meter, SAS 300-C (SWEDEN)

2)      Resistivity meter – CRM-50, ANVIC (INDIA)

3)      VLF EM unit (BRGM-France)

4)      Geophysical logger (UPTRON- INDIA)

5)      Digital logger-Portable (OYO 3030-JAPAN)

6)      Digital logger-Discrete measurement (ABEM Terra meter SAS 200 SWEDEN)

 
 
Geophysical Investigations TOP
 

A large part of Maharashtra state and the Union Territories of Dadra and Nagar Haveli is underlain by hard rock strata particularly by Deccan Basaltic flows [81% of the total area] with localized occurrences of sedimentary and alluvial formations. The surface geophysical investigations, in the region are being carried out mainly for

1) The site selection for exploration drilling

2) Artificial recharge studies

3) Site selection for water supply schemes for local bodies, defense establishments and other governmental agencies etc.

4) Special investigations like pollution studies and supportive studies for systematic/reappraisal hydrogeological surveys.

5)  Special investigations for drought affected areas in order to reduce well failures and rejection of negative areas.

Apart from the above, subsurface geophysical investigations like bore hole logging is also carried out as a post drilling operation for recommending well design etc. Though most of the surveys are demand based, as far as ground water exploration is concerned, Board has the geophysical capabilities of mapping bed-rock topography in rocks, locating fresh water aquifers in saline environments, identifying the direction of ground water movement and seepage, locating favourable areas for artificial recharge schemes, mapping pollution plumes and locating the ground water potential zones for restoring water supply as a part of drought / disaster management.

Methodology:
The aim of Geophysical investigations is to look for the contrast between the physical properties of the target and its surroundings. As such more the contrast/anomaly better would be the geophysical response and hence identification of the target. There are different techniques of which some are responsive to hydrogeological heterogeneities while others are not. Accordingly, one or more suitable techniques/methods are employed for effective delineation of the target – in this case the water bearing formations, for example a weathered/fractured zone in hard rock, sand/gravel zones in alluvial formations. The most commonly used geophysical method in ground water exploration is electrical resistivity method as the response is both qualitative and quantitative.

 
Investigations in Different Terrains TOP
  The geophysical investigations are focused mainly in Deccan trap areas, Gondwana formations and in alluvial formation. Some of the case studies are 
presented below:
 
 
Deccan traps  
 

The Deccan Traps (Basaltic lava flows) pose as serious challenge to the geophysical surveys. These traps comprise a series of near horizontal lava flows and again each flow consists of 3-4 sub-litho units, viz. top weathered basalt. followed by fractured/vesicular/jointed basalt and compact and massive basalt at the base of the flow.

The weathered, jointed/fractured/vesicular basalts and at times the contact between two successive flows are also favourable zones to form potential aquifers.
Each geoelectric layer obtained by the investigations is not exactly the response from the individual litho units but the response of equivalent resistivity or the weighted average of number of subsurface litho units.  

Techniques like Vertical Electrical Soundings (VES), radial VES, gradient resistivity profiling, along with various interpretational techniques like inverse slope, curve matching and curve break methods were used to achieve the objective. It is  observed that a low resistive geo electric layer sandwiched between two high resistive layers proved to be potential zone.
The surface geophysical surveys and borehole logging were carried out in this terrain.
   
 
Granites  
 
In granitic terrain the ground water is confined mainly to the weathered and semi-weathered layers, fractured and jointed portion of the rock. Sustainable development of ground water needs tapping of saturated high yielding fracture zones. The surface geophysical surveys and borehole logging were carried out in granitic terrain in parts of Nagpur, Bhandara and Chandrapur districts.
 
 
Gondwanas  
 
he Gondwanas comprise of sandstones, shales, quartzites ,sands, coal seams etc. The Gondwana formations are less consolidated than the Pre-cambrian sedimentary rocks. The aim of geophysical investigations is to demarcate the sandstone/sand beds, which are ground water repositories from clastic sediments. Apart from differentiating the coal seams in comparatively hard and compact sandstone areas, geophysical investigations look also for the secondary porosities that developed due to weathering and fracturing. These surveys were carried out in parts of Nagpur, Bhandara and Chandrapur districts where the Gondwana formations exist.
 
  Standardisation of Resistivity Values TOP
 
Alluvial Formation
 
Alluvial areas are the most potential zones when they have favourable recharge conditions and sufficient thicknesses. Alluvium is found in most of the river basins and usually consists of layers of clays, sands of different gradations, gravels and boulders. The success of a well in alluvial tracts depends on the presence of coarse grained beds, like sands and gravels. The resistivity surveys were carried out in parts of Nagpur, Amaravati, Akola and Jalgaon districts.
 

Overlapping resistivity ranges and very wide range of resistivities make it difficult to characterize ground water targets unless standardized locally. With the available database in the region, the following resistivity ranges were established for different litho units vis-à-vis water bearing zones.

 


Deccan Basalts

 

Litho Unit

Resistivity in Ohm m

 

Black cotton soil and Bole bed

5-10

 

Weathered/fractured vesicular basalt saturated with water

20-45

 

Moderately weathered/fractured basalt/vesicular basalt saturated with water

40-70

 

Hard and massive basalt

> 70

 

 

 

 

Granites

Litho Unit

Resistivity in Ohm m

  Highly weathered granite

20-50

  Semi weathered granite

50-120

  Fractured/jointed granite

120-200

  Massive granite

> 300
Gondwanas

Litho Unit

Resistivity in Ohm m

 

Water saturated/highly weathered sand stones

< 50

 

Fractured sand stones

50-300

 

Hard and compact sand stones

>300

 

 

 

 

Alluvium

 

 

Litho Unit

Resistivity in Ohm m

 

Clay

< 10

 

Sand with clay

10-20

 

Sand

20-50

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
Case Studies -I TOP
 
 
I. SINDHKHED ( TALUK: KINWAT, DISTRICT: NANDED )  
 


The gneisses and granites of older Precambrian, capped by basaltic flows with intertrappean beds of upper cretaceous to lower Eocene period form the major geological formations of the district. Extensive outcrop of the granites are found in the Southeastern parts of the district along its border with Andhra Pradesh. Thin beds of nodular limestone and gray sandstone occur below the Deccan trap.

 

In this village a Gradient Resisitivity Profile (GRP) was carried out with the current electrode separation (AB) of 500m. and the potential electrode separation of 20m. The central part of the array, having a length of 180m was scanned by measuring resistivities at an interval of 10m. The orientation of the profile was kept NW-SE. On the same line of the GRP a Wenner Resistivity Profile (WRP-a) was run from 50m south east of zero station of the GRP. Also a parallel Wenner Resistivity Profile (WRP-b) was taken 36 m NE of WRP-a. All the three profiles (Fig.) have shown the same pattern of resistivities, increasing from southeast to northwest. Vertical Electrical Soundings (VES) were also conducted at the zero station of GRP (VES-1), on WRP-a at 200m northwest from the zero station of the GRP (VES-2) and at 40m.SE of the zero station of the GRP on WRP-b (VES-3). On the basis of resistivity lows on GRP and WRP-a, the site was recommended at the zero station of the GRP. The borehole drilled down to a depth of 120 m at this point has yielded 12.18 lps. However an observation well drilled at 20m NE of the exploration well, which is on a resistivity high of WRP-b has yielded only 0.14 lps.

 
 
 
 
 
II. LOHARA (TALUK: KARANJA, DISTRICT: AKOLA)  
 


The vast area of the district is occupied by the Deccan trap formation, which comprises near horizontal basaltic lava flows, belonging to the upper Cretaceous to lower Eocene age.

 

In this village, a gradient resistivity profile (GRP) with a current electrode separation of 400m and potential electrode separation of 40m was conducted. On the same line of GRP a Wenner resistivity profile was carried out. Both resistivity profiles have shown the decreasing trend of resistivity towards north. A VES was carried out on the common resistivity low of both the profiles and the site was recommended for drilling and the well drilled down to a depth of 128m has yielded a discharge of 4.43lps.

 
 
 
III. Geophysical Investigations at Kanhan River for the augmentation of water supply, Nagpur Municipal Corporation  
 

A short-term investigation was taken up for the augmentation of water supply to Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) at a site in Knhan River alluvium near Kamptee town. Hydrogeological and geophysical investigations were carried out at this site in order to delineate the nature and thickness of the alluvial sediments in the river and for selecting a suitable site for the construction of collector well. In all 11 VES were carried out in 3 sq.km area (Fig.). The VES-1 and 3 are located on a sand bar forming a small island towards the bank. VES-4 is located at the adjoining sand bar, VES-6 and 7 are located on another adjoining sand bar. The VES-5, 8 and 9 are located on the northern edge of Kanhan river. VES-10 and 11 are located upstream side of the weir on Kanhan river.

 

Based on the resistivity data a fence diagram (Fig.) was prepared to see the disposition   of the sand layer and to recommend the sites for the collector wells. This diagram indicates that the sand thickness vary from 5.6m (at VES-6) to more than 35m (at VES-11). Similarly the fence diagram shows that the sand thickness is maximum at VES-2 (38m), which falls on the sand island adjoining the southern bank after the confluence or the rivers. The sand thickness decreases towards east. The site at VES-2 is considered as the suitable site for the construction of the collector well. The collector well , however, is to be located in the river bed, so that the radials are directly below the river bed.

 

Two more sites at VES-4 (on the adjoining sand island which lie to the center of the river) and at the VES-11, locate to the north of the weir on the Kanhan river can be considered. The sand thickness at these two sites is 28m and 35m respectively. These two sites are also suitable for the radial collector wells and can be considered as alternative or additional sites for the future use.
 
 
Based on the interpretation of the data, a geoelectric section (fig.) has been prepared which reveals that the top most layer being unsaturated (dry sand), show very high resistivity which varies from 250-2900 Ohm-m and its thickness varies from 0.4-2.9m. The second layer is saturated sand with resistivity ranging from 35-180 Ohm-m and thickness from 0.8-8.4m. Below this sand bed, a clay bed of up to 34m occur exhibiting very low resistivity values from 5-9 Ohm-m. The clay bed is absent from the intake wells of NMC and the saturated sands directly overlie the lateritic silty clay, whose thickness is up to 30m. These investigations have revealed availability of sand with variable thickness of 8-40m , whose thickness is upto 38m. These sediments forming the river alluvium are underlined by a lateritic silty clay over the base of Kampthi sand stones. The considerable sand thickness is interpreted from the VES at three sites viz. at VES-2,4 and 11. Of these the site at VES-2, where the sand thickness is 38m is selected for the construction of the collector well with 8 numbers of radially arranged laterals.
 
 
Artificial Recharge Studies TOP
   
 
The artificial recharge project is a site specific and is based on local hydrogeological and hydrological environments. The first step in planning the project is to demarcate the area for recharge/conservation and building a site specific structure there.

Some of the criteria adopted are high water percolation rate, presence of suitable unsaturated granular zone for effective water storage and shallow depth to compact rock at the site of artificial recharge structure. Electrical resistivity and electromagnetic methods can differentiate water saturated and unsaturated portion of the formations based on their resistivity contrasts. 

Refraction seismic techniques posses high success rate in identifying fractured part of the rock and map compact rock topography. This is based on the velocity contrast of the elastic waves (generated artificially) in different subsurface formations. However in unconsolidated sediments electrical resistivity methods are quite effective in locating the permeable granular zone and its lateral extent. The method is also suitable to map interface between fractured and compact rock formations. At shallow depth Very Low Frequency (VLF) electromagnetic technique is very successful in mapping the lateral extent of consolidated and unconsolidated parts of the formations. Similarly the movement of the ground water can be ascertained by carrying out Self Potential (SP) surveys. Combination of different techniques is finally the requirement for selection of suitable sites for construction of artificial recharge structures.

 
The geophysicaal techniques can be utilized for pin pointing the sites for constructing the type of the structure.

1) Storage structure - hard formation
2) Percolation/Recharge structure - Soft/ Weathered formation
By geophysical techniques the location, extent and depth of hard/saturated/weathered zones can be deciphered for building a site specific structure. If it is to construct a recharge/percolation structure, a weak/unsaturated/weathered formation is required. But if it is to construct a storage structure the objective of geophysical surveys is to delineate a hard formation.
 
 
Case Studies-II TOP
 
 TE-17 WATERSHED, TALUKA:YAVAL, DISTRICT:JALGAON  
 

Surface geophysical investigations were carried out in the watershed to supplement the sub surface data about the aquifer geometry for artificial recharge with the objective of:

a)      Determining the regional aquifer geometry

b)      Determining the granular zone above the water table

c)       Investigate the presence of granular zones at the injection well sites.

 

Schlumberger Electrode Array was used for determining the regional aquifer geometry. VES were taken along two traverses from North to South at an interval of 2 km. Apart from these a few VES were also taken in the remaining part of the watershed. In total 95 VES were taken (Fig.). It is observed that in the watershed that the clay content is more between 70-80mbgl and above it 3-6 granular horizons are encountered. Further, there is great heterogeneity and granular horizons show pinching and swelling at depths.

 

In order to know the percentage of granular horizons above the water level, Wenner configuration was used with an increment of 0.5m for the electrode separation (a) to pick up thin horizons. In all, 68 sites were investigated. 3-4 granular horizons were inferred above the water table. The area having maximum percentage of granular content is ideal for ground water recharge. From the perusal of Fig., the following inferences are made.

1. The percentage of granular zone is the least (<50%) along the northern bank of Tapi River.

2. The percentage of granular zone increases from <50% (in the South of the study area) to >80% (in the central part) and again starts decreasing towards north to a low of 50%.

 
AMARAVATI DISTRICT - MAPPING BEDROCK TOPOGRAPHY


Geophysical resistivity surveys were carried out in parts of Amravati district, to support the Reappraisal Hydrogeological Studies in mapping the bedrock topography. Geologically the area is occupied by two formations. Viz. the Deccan lava flows and the alluvium deposits comprising of clay, silt, sand and gravel. 21 Vertical Electrical Soundings (VES) were carried out and based on the interpreted VES results a contour map showing the bedrock topography was generated. (Fig.)
 

The bedrock in the area has a general northerly dip. From the contour map it can be seen that the bed-rock in the southern part of the area is as shallow as 15m at Bhatkuli and is increasing towards north. The maximum depth of 98m is noticed at Talwel Phata in the northern part of the area. It is also seen that the bedrock topography between Bhatkuli and Asti is smoothly varying from 15m to 91m without any undulations whereas it is undulated between Asti to Talwel. The bedrock is fairly uniform in the east-west direction in the entire area, with an exception in the northeastern side where it is dipping gently towards east. It is further noticed that the bed-rock contours are closing around Asti with maximum depth of 91m at Asti suggesting a valley like feature. Similarly in the northeastern part of the study area contours are elongated in NW-SE direction indicating a probable lineament.

 

Geophysical Logging

TOP


Geophysical logging is the measurement of depth wise variations of electrical and physical properties in a borehole. It is the post drilling approach to optimize the design and development of well. In ground water exploration, the commonly measured parameters are Self Potential (SP), Point Resistance (PR), Short and Long Normal resistivities, Lateral and natural Gamma.  However other techniques like Caliper  logging (for diameter of borehole), Neutron-Neutron logging and flow logging were also carried out as and when required. Logging of bore holes is carried out to obtain information on

·          The occurrence, and quality of water in the geological formation

·          The physical characteristics of geological formation through which the bore hole is drilled

·          The dimension, construction and physical condition of the bore hole

·           Percentage contribution of ground water from each aquifer

Depending on the instrumentation involved, three types of measurements are in vogue viz.

1.       Discrete measurements where parameters are measured at regular intervals of depth, at points of interest and plotted on linear scale. 

2.       Analog measurements where continuous depth wise recording of parameters is done on a chart paper .

3.       Digital measurement, where the parameters are recorded digitally. The advantage with this type is the data can be stored on digital storage media for further analysis on computer and for reproducing logs at desired scales.


Central Region is equipped with all the above three types of loggers and typical geophysical logs acquired with them are presented in Fig.1, Fig. 2  and  Fig 3

Case   Studies III                                                       

TOP

A. The exploratory well drilled at the village Khandala, Nagpur district was logged using the Digital logger- (ABEM Terra meter SAS 200 SWEDEN) to a depth of 185m. The Self Potential (SP) and Normal resistivities were recorded at intervals of 1 m and the plotted log was presented in the (Fig.). From the analysis of the logs it is inferred that the granular zones occur between the following depth ranges.

8-19m, 24-42.5m, 49-51m, 53-57m(mixed with shale), 65-73m, 77.5-86.5m, 91.5-101m, 105-114m, 116-120m(mixed with shale), 120-126.5m, 143-146m, 148-153m, 160-164.5m, 171-176m and 179-182. mbgl.

 

B. A pilot borehole drilled at the village Pathansawangi, Savner Taluk, Nagpur district was logged with the UPTRON analog logger. The Self Potential (SP), and Normal resistivities were recorded and the log was presented in the Fig. From the analysis of the logs it is inferred that the granular zones occur between the depth ranges.

 

32-45m, 47-50m, 54-72m(61-62m clay ) 82-89m, 93-100m, 108-115m, 124-129m, 136-139m, 144-150m, 164-168m and 176-178mbgl

C. The bore hole drilled at Vavarde, Jalgaon district under Out Sourcing Exploratory Drilling programme was logged down to a depth of 200m by OYO portable digital logger and the parameters measured were Self Potential, Short and Long Normal Resistivities and Natural Gamma. (Fig.) As the log was recorded in hard rock terrain, the response of SP was not amenable for interpretation. As such, the interpretation is based on resistivity and gamma logs only. The values observed for different litho-units are as follows.

 

                       Litho unit                  Resistivity  (Ohm m)                          Gamma counts (CPS)

                 Weathered basalt                   30-80                                                      10-25

         Amygdaloidal/jointed basalt            80-150                                                      5-10

                   Massive basalt                    100-250                                                     2-10

     

     Based on these values, more than 10 different flows were demarcated and the flow tops have been demarcated based on the presence of Weathered basalt/Amygdaloidal basalt immediately below the massive basalt. These can be clearly seen at the following depths.

    

     7-9m, 14m, 39-43m, 46-48m, 63-65m, 71-73m, 97-98m, 105-106m, 110m, 117m, 126-127m, 137-138m, 150-151m, 157-158m, 164-167m, 194-196m